Allahabad HC Fines Noida Builder ₹2.5 Lakh Over 13-Year Delay
The Allahabad High Court has upheld 24% annual interest for delayed possession and imposed ₹2.5 lakh in costs on a Noida developer over prolonged litigation.
- Homebuyer paid ₹35.90 lakh for a flat in Sector 75, Noida.
- Possession was promised by June 2013 but was not delivered as agreed.
- Court said prolonged litigation cannot defeat a homebuyer’s rights.
Noida: The Allahabad High Court has imposed a ₹2.5 lakh cost on Aims Max Gardenia Developers Pvt. Ltd. after a Noida homebuyer spent nearly 13 years pursuing possession and enforcement of orders related to her flat. The court also upheld the 24% annual interest awarded for the delayed possession.
The dispute concerns Pratibha Gupta’s flat in the Golf City project in Sector 75, Noida. She had paid around ₹35.90 lakh for the property under an agreement signed in April 2011, with possession originally scheduled for June 2013. The developer failed to meet that commitment. The case was ultimately heard by the Allahabad High Court in proceedings involving the builder’s challenge to the RERA-related orders.
After the promised possession date passed, Pratibha Gupta approached the Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) in Gautam Buddha Nagar. In July 2018, the authority directed the developer to hand over possession and pay 24% interest per annum from June 30, 2013.
The developer did not comply with the order, leading to execution proceedings. A recovery certificate of about ₹41.21 lakh was subsequently issued in March 2019. The builder challenged the recovery process before the Uttar Pradesh Real Estate Appellate Tribunal and later moved the Allahabad High Court.
The dispute continued through multiple proceedings. According to the court record, the builder’s appeal before the tribunal was dismissed for want of prosecution and had earlier faced dismissal on the same ground. The homebuyer also approached the High Court for enforcement of the recovery certificate and initiated contempt proceedings when the order remained unenforced.
The High Court did not accept the developer’s reliance on disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic as sufficient justification for the prolonged delay. The court found that the developer had not demonstrated the reasonable diligence required to fulfil its obligations.
The court also upheld the 24% interest rate awarded to the homebuyer. A key point was the contractual interest provision: where the agreement specifies an interest rate that a buyer must pay for delayed payments, the same rate can be relevant when determining the builder’s liability for delayed possession.
The court further emphasized that possession cannot simply be treated as complete without the required occupancy certificate.
The judgment is significant for homebuyers dealing with long-running possession disputes. It shows that obtaining a favourable RERA order may not always end the matter if the developer challenges or delays its enforcement.
The ₹2.5 lakh cost also adds another financial consequence for the developer. The court described the case as one where exemplary costs were justified, noting that the homebuyer had been forced to pursue multiple rounds of litigation for years despite having no fault in the delay.
For buyers, the case also highlights the importance of checking the possession date mentioned in the agreement, maintaining records of payments and correspondence, and pursuing enforcement when a regulatory order is not followed.
The court’s decision strengthens the homebuyer’s position in the long-running dispute by upholding the RERA-awarded interest and imposing additional costs on the developer. The case also serves as a reminder that developers cannot avoid financial liability simply by prolonging litigation after a regulatory authority has already passed an order.
For homebuyers facing delayed possession, the ruling underlines the importance of RERA orders, recovery proceedings and proper documentation when seeking enforcement of their contractual and statutory rights.
Also Read: NCLT Approves Rs 367.93-Crore Resolution Plan for Three C Green Developers
